More Maths Problems
The content of A Level exams is under fire yet again after a report by Score (Science community representing education) has suggested that A Level science papers do not contain enough maths-based content to adequately prepare students to take on science degrees.
Graham Hutchings, who is the chairman of Score told the BBC, “Our findings are worrying. A significant proportion of the mathematical requirements put in place by the examinations regulator, Ofqual, for each of the sciences were simply not assessed and, if they were, it was often in a very limited way.”
Hutchings is particularly concerned about how the A Level science syllabus is missing key areas of maths, which underpin a lot of scientific topics. For example, calculus and converting between different units are not taught in many schools. Some exam boards assess more maths than others, but this disparity is also worrying because it means that students will have very different knowledge bases according to which exam they sit.
With the exam boards leaving out key areas that are essential to the study of the sciences at degree level, pupils are just going to have a much tougher time at university. Already many universities (as reported in a blog last week) need to offer remedial classes to first students who arrive as undergraduates without sufficient knowledge and skills to confidently begin BA courses. This shouldn’t need to happen; universities should not have to make up for poor teaching at school, and instead they should be able to imediately start expanding and challenging undergraduates’ knowledge and thinking.
Unfortunately it isn’t only the science A Levels that don’t contain enough maths; when the Nuffield Foundation looked at the A Level papers for economics, geography, psychology, computing, business studies and sociology in 2010 their report “concluded that with the exception of computing, the variation in mathematical content was so great that the qualifications did not give universities or employers a meaningful indication of students’ level of mathematical skill or understanding.” (Judith Burns, BBC).
These reports add further evidence to the argument that universities and employers should be more involved in designing A Level courses, so that they don’t exist in a bubble and can more adequately prepare students for the demands of employment and degrees.
